Permission vs Consent

Issue/Topic: Permission and Consent

Monday – Session 3 - F

Conference: IIW10 May 17-19, 2009 this is the complete Complete Set of Notes

Convener: Kevin Marks

Notes-taker(s): Stacey Pitsillides

Notable URLS: Proposal discussed - http://habitatchronicles.com/2009/12/the-cake-is-a-lie-reputation-facebook-apps-and-consent-user-interfaces/

Video of Session: http://idcoach.blip.tv/file/3642333/

Discussion Notes:

• User name/ password model
• More comprehensible to people
• You were doing what with my stuff???
• Meaningful choice about what I’m providing
• How many users they’ve got to sign up/ not how many users understand
• what they’ve signed up for.
• What am I giving permission for this thing to do?
• Is this app gonna do something bad to me, do people I know and trust, trust it
• App invites – neg half of it
• The app is able to deduce who my friends are?
• Holding the app – personal context
• Quality, copy, disappointment
• Permissions you give to that app
• Disclosure- this app demands these things and you cant switch them off
• Binary yes or no!
• Info to help you make your choice
• “we need you e-mail” wait till you have the reason to answer the
• question - gets them more e-mail addys that you cannot use
• trade- want that- prove your value
• know when your gonna use it
• bring the user to you ?? design system so
• consent for sharing – abstract idea of groups
• delegating identity back to you – empathy
• statement of purpose
• the cake is a lie – Randy Farmer
• specific statements of claims – say the following things on my app-
• when you make an assertion…. Separation between app provider
• classify apps – different ?
• im a level 3 guaranteed app
• set of purposes mapped to a set of capabilities
• sensitivity of information – defaults – exception – purpose statements
• compared to categories
• redemption ? new app 0 is better then -5 ask forgiveness button /
• reputation decay ?
• post on my behalf
• this spams me
• promises, drag the canneries in – initial promise
• how you develop trust?
• Abuse mitigation tool
• Curated computing - social curation within an app store
• How do you scale trust without a legal framework ??